References To The Flea
We don't know much about the Flea yet. Here are the mentions of the Flea so far (please add more if you know of them).
-
MaydayTextFleaSNakedFoot "It happened one day, about noon, going towards my boat, I was exceedingly surprised with the print of a flea's naked foot on the shore, which was very plain to be seen on the sand."
-
TheStory "Meanwhile, the Pious Flea was so small that even the Widow, with her sharp eyes, could hardly see him, and when she looked his way, he hid."
-
PhaseEmailsFromLadybeeAugustRd "MARK but this flea, and mark in this / don‰??t like it / I can't help it / a proper fool / a bad banana / unimaginable filth and stench; and disease / he can't write his name or read a book "
-
TheKillerJpg "Perhaps you are the Pious Flea? / Seek the truth / Behold the truth / That is the law and the whole of the law / Nasty little infestation"
-
PhaseComputerCode Enormous find in Phase 3 which seems to peg the Flea as a (semi-) intelligent AI battling the Spider.
-
AugustThPrincessMonologue The Princess's description of the Phase 3 computer code.
-
PhaseMessageFromSleepingPrincess In the message from 8/26/2004: "I scrunched up real small on the next to last stair and I put on my listening ears and I listened super hard. I could hear the Flea whispering to her [the Queen]. Finally I stuck my head up above the top stair and then I could hear the Flea telling her to build some little teeny roads. Secret paths." The roads (or 'secret paths') likely refer to axons.
-
YellowBrickRoad The Princess recounts her last conversation with the Pious Flea at
http://www.ilovebees.com/yellowbrickroad.html, given in a combination of computer code and speech. This hidden page was found by unscrambling single words embedded into images.
Speculation on the Flea
After sleeping on it, I'd like to offer an alternative theory about the Pious Flea. I believe the Pious Flea is the entity who is receiving communications via the ladybee777 e-mail account and responding through the the KillerJpg embedded text. My logic is as follows:
-
In the TheStory of the Widow's Journey, we are never told that TheSleepingPrincess is doing anything but sleeping, yet the Pious Flea is described as "so small that even the Widow, with her sharp eyes, could hardly see him, and when she looked his way, he hid."
-
In the KillerJpg "Killer 12" and "Killer 13" variant, the entity says, "the Queen was wondering how long the Sleeping Princess would keep if stored in an airtight container. I can only watch from the shadows, piecing together what I may", and "I am fine, have the necessary tools to hide hard in the darkness". This hiding motif seems to match up more closely with the description of the Flea in the Widow's Journey than with the Princess. Plus, if the entity is indeed the Princess, this would be the first and only time it referred to itself in the third person rather than the first (i.e. the entity doesn't say "the Queen was wondering how long I would keep if stored in an airtight container").
-
If the Spider is some sort of automated recovery tool for the Queen, why wouldn't other insect-like characters serve similar functions? Clearly the KillerJpg entity has some repair/protection functions available to it, as we see in the "Killer 9" variant - "I believe I can help you out, I can apply a construct to protect your core".
-
From the KillerJpg "Killer 1" variant, we know the Spider has talked to the entity directly - "Before I woke up I dreamed what the Widow said in processing mode More direct communication with me". In the absence of better information, wouldn't it make sense for the Spider to talk to the Flea than for the Spider to talk to the Sleeping Princess? To anticipate counterclaims to the "Killer 1" text, claiming that you've woken up doesn't make you the Sleeping Princess. Again, the Sleeping Princess has never been characterized as anything but "sleeping" and The Queen/The Operator/Melissa has also claimed to have woken up (and indeed is still in the process of waking up with the Widow/Spider/SPDR's aid).
-
Much has been made of the KillerJpg "Killer 2" variant, in which the entity says, "I am some kid who wants to get noticed, very clever an instigator an innocent bystander stored in an airtight container in the deepest and darkest Sleeping casket in a chamber of the dungeon", with people claiming that the entity was stored in an airtight casket, therefore the entity is the Princess. The Flea could have been in the casket with the Princess, trying to take care of her - even feeding her (as the "Killer 4" variant's embedded text implies) and trying to make her surroundings more comfortable (as the ebmedded text of the "Killer 3" variant suggests).
-
Also, note that if extern 2 is the Flea, the Widow did make contact, because she got the "!net act | drop." See WidowsJourneyComputerTextComparison and its discussion. --UserKhaim 16:31, 28 Jul 2004 (PDT)
- I believe UserExtrasonic is suggesting parallels with the myth of
Comatas-STKenyan
-
Finally, there's the KillerJpg "Killer 7" variant. "Question: Perhaps you are the Pious Flea / Answers: Seek the truth / Behold the truth / That is the law and the whole of the law". This one could be interpreted either way ("Behold the truth" i.e. you've got it right, or "Seek the truth" i.e. try again), but you should probably lean toward confirmation rather than denial since this is the only question about its identity that the entity has devoted an entire Killer variant to, despite the The Etymologician's many questions on this subject in his TheEmails.
--UserExtrasonic 05:25, 28 Jul 2004 (PDT)
Re: Killer 7: Aren't Killers 10 and 12 also devoted entirely to identity? -UserKoi 20:24, 28 Jul 2004 (EDT)
-
I thought this was really interesting. I searched for Pious on Google and this is what I found:
"PIOUS is a complete Parallel I/O System for the PVM 3 distributed computing environment. Just as PVM implements a virtual multicomputer on top of a heterogeneous network of computing resources, PIOUS implements a fully functional parallel file system on top of PVM. PVM applications obtain transparent access to shared permanent storage via PIOUS library functions.
-
PIOUS is intended to serve both as a platform for supporting high-performance parallel applications, and as a vehicle for parallel file system research. PIOUS implements the traditional functionality found in most parallel computer file systems, as well as a number of unique features, including:
two-dimensional file objects and logical file views, coordinated file access with guaranteed consistency semantics, data declustering for scalable performance, transaction support and user-selectable fault tolerance modes, extended file maintenance primitives for managing declustered files, and C and Fortran language bindings. PIOUS should work on most systems that support PVM 3. To date, PIOUS has been tested on the following: Sun4/SunOS 4.1.3/5.3-4, SGI/IRIX 4.0.5/5.3, Dec Alpha/OSF1 2.1, HP 9000/HP-UX, and IBM RS6000/AIX. Versions of PIOUS are installed at hundreds of sites, and the software appears to be stable.
The PIOUS project is supported in part by U. S. DoE, MICS grant DE-FG05-91ER25105, and NSF awards ASC-9527186, and CCR-9523544."
I'm guessing that the pious flea is based off of this program. I think what the PIOUS program is in summary is it is Library for C/C++ programming that allows the user to be "invisible" to others...or a flea...hardly visible to the Widow because it was a PIOUS Flea...okay...I just hit something:
The PIOUS Flea is a transparent/invisible program (what it's purpose is I dunno) that is spying on the Queen/Widow...it wasn't seen by the Widow, not because it's the size of a flea, but because it is an invisible program. Like modern SpyWare.
Here's the link to what I found: http://www.mathcs.emory.edu/pious/
No need to get all uppity about what I said. I was just trying to shed some light on the situation. - Icicle2004
-
Icicle2004's explanation of the Flea seems very unlikely - all the AIs seem to think of real-world human technology as being very basic yet they have trouble keeping track of the Flea. If Icicle2004 is correct on this, I will eat my hat. -- UserClamatius 17:36, 29 Jul 2004 (PDT)
-
You may have to learn to like the flavour of hat, Clamatius.
Remember that the Robinson Crusoe reference substitutes "flea" for "man". This could be a clue that we should look at the Pious Flea as a substitute for Friday... a native of the sandy shore upon which our Castaway has found him/herself. If so, the Flea could be a process (or collection of processes) native to the new network that SPDR and the Operator now reside in; one that doesn't draw many resources and is hard for SPDR to detect.--UserAntonPNym 17:56, 29 Jul 2004 (PDT)
-
I always think you can get anything down with enough ketchup...
However, I'm still pretty sure I'm right. UserIcicle's explanation of what the real-world PIOUS library is is not correct. As it says in the text UserIcicle quotes, it's not something that lets programs be "invisible". It's a distributed file system library, nothing more, nothing less. -- UserClamatius 18:04, 29 Jul 2004 (PDT)
-
I agree with Clamatius. After all, in the real world we don't have AIs yet, so how can the Flea be native? If Pious refers to anything, it's probably the ethical nature of the Flea. It could also be a reference to religion and the position of the clergy in the court; after all, this story has strong overtones of a fairy tale. --UserKhaim 18:10, 29 Jul 2004 (PDT)
-
Yeah, that'd be a stumbler unless they want us to think in Skynet terms. As far as the Pious part, maybe I was hoping for terrestrial origin because otherwise we're looking in Halo terms; the Covenant is a theocracy, and their piety ("whose primary form of worship apparently takes place at the altar of orbital bombardment")
http://marathon.bungie.org/story/cortana.html#4 isn't anything I'm looking forward to seeing in-game!--UserAntonPNym 18:23, 29 Jul 2004 (PDT)
-
I sorta agree with Icicle2004, but not entirely. It seems to me that PIOUS, being a filesystem, would be tasked with finding, organizing, and presenting data to the user, no? It occurs to me that this is exactly what the Pious Flea is doing, spying on the actions of The Operator and SPDR, and reporting it's findings to us. As to the origin of the Flea, I'm betting he's not native, at least not completely. He could be some sort of failsafe spyware installed in The Operator, or he could be a local program that somehow fused with an errant peice of The Op. --UserDruhol 18:33, 29 Jul 2004 (PDT)?
-
I believe the Pious Flea is a subroutine of the Sleeping Princess AI, which would explain his confusion about identity. See my TheONI page for details. UserTankRamp 19:50, 29 Jul 2004 (PDT)
-
All very good spec here, I believe that the fly most likely is as icicle says a small invisible program, but not neccasarily because of the PIOUS, but simply because the widow has trouble seeing it or detecting it, and we must remember that all these stories are metaphorical to an entity/entities on a computer, i personally see the fly has being very similar to spyware: hidden but with the possiblity of causing lots of annoyance and damage. Also believe him to be native to the system as he is "awakened" with the rest, possibly planted like a virus (flea is a parasite in real life, why not a virus then?) this is way out there, and i don't have time to collect the evidence to support this but from discussion on #beekeepers possibly planted by the hitchhiker (the guy planting buoys) into melissa. UserTroyMcClure 20:16, 29 Jul 2004 (PDT)
We should not discount the input of the other characters in determining what the Flea is. The SPDR looks for other running processes it can identify and finds only the Flea and the Princess. However, the Operator's Monologue makes reference to being aware of Dana's anti-virus. Why didn't the SPDR notice these local processes? The answer is that SPDR only recognizes parts of the Melissa AI, making the Flea part of Melissa and NOT a local program gone astray like the Robinson Carusoe reference may imply. That reference is probably a red herring.
The fact that the Flea is an 'invisible' program is quite evident from the Widow-SPDR story as well as the other in-game references. The PIOUS connection is superfluous and beats the horse well past dead. Let's look to more obscure facets of the story. --UserNoir
Perhaps its not that the flea is invisble, its just a very small program. The reference in the story about it being "[so small the Widow could hardly see it], and when she looked its way, it hid" doesn't mean its invisible, just that it is hard to find. The Sleeping Princess also seemed to dislike the flea, meaning that at least one other character knows about it, or has found it. Currently there are very small programs designed to damage computers (such as the smoke auto downloader, which is only 5kb, nearly unoticeable if embedded in something). It could be the flea is some sort of very basic program, which eventually helps with the destruction of another (not doing much damage itself). If we pretend the flea is designed to put a trojan onto the hard dirve or into the AI, then it could being a small program. The reference to it hiding can also be linked with embedding a file. Its also possible that its size is just relative, because we know the human AIs would need to be very large to show personalities and actually seem intelligent. The flea could actually be a program large by today's standards, but very small in the future, meaning it may be a primitive AI. This fits in with the fact that the covenant do not have advanced AIs, and there was reference to one very basic covenant AI that a Human AI came in contact with. -- UserFaukYu
Icicle's speculation is almost certainly incorrect. PLEASE people, let's remember that the names used in the TheStory are all allegorical - TheOperator is referred to as TheQueen, the TheSPDR is referred to as TheWidow, etc. Even if ThePiousFlea were a literal name given to that entity outside the TheStory, like all of the other acronyms we have encounted so far (TheONI, TheSPDR, etc.), Icicle's speculation would be extremely far-fetched - as a name inside the TheStory, it just doesn't work at all. TheOperator's allegorical name is TheQueen due to her behavior and, arguably, the TheSPDR's allegorical name is TheWidow for behavioral reasons as well, in a reference to Black Widow spiders (given how she dispatched the TheManticore). The as-of-yet undiscovered literal equivalent of the ThePiousFlea is probably named as such in the TheStory because of his behavior also - pious due to his loyalty/ethics, and flea because he's a burrowing, parasitic creature, either literally or metaphorically. --UserExtrasonic
-
Well I didn't mean literally a program running off this PIOUS thing. I just meant that the Pious Flea's behaviour/attitude could be derived from this program. But yeah, I read the website wrong, there isn't really any way someone can't be seen by another user while hacking/reverse-engineering/veiwing or whatever. Though isn't that what a user can do in AIM...he's "invisible" to other users? - Icicle2004
-
I started to bash out a theory, but the supporting evidence was bulking it out too much: I'll create a new page for it here: FleaAsCovenantTrojan --UserAntonPNym 16:38, 30 Jul 2004 (PDT)
-
In AlternateComputerTextComparison, the only time the SPDR/Widow uses her !bite command is after discovering the rogue "external process #1", which seems to be the Flea . The Manticore she just !kills. Curious. (Probably she only has !kill jurisdiction over internal processes.) It has also been noted that this attack (which ends with "clean confidence 97%") does not appear in the allegory as an attack. --jellyfish_green, 3 Aug 2004
-
Another theory on the nature of the Flea, based on the name. Both 'pious' and 'flea' are curious vowel-heavy words, and between them contain all five vowels, each one once, in something that's not far off their correct order. If you assume that's not a coincidence and ditch the vowels, you're left with the letters PSFL. Now, we already know of the existence of TheSPDR -- the 'System Peril Distributed Reflex'. Are we looking at communications from/about SPFL or SPLF, another component of the System Peril system? (Added after further thought: LF could conceivably be 'Log File' which seems -- to me -- to be what the Flea does, in terms of ordering and archiving information on what's happening within the system. Yes, I know the letters are backwards but so are the digits on the Ilovebees countdown. Note that Sleeping Princess is another SP. Of course, it all may be random letters turning up by chance.) -- YojimboUK, 2004-08-04
-
Think you guys shouldnt try to get too much obscure meaining out of the word Pius other than its esential meaning of being Humble. Yojimbo might be on to something but i think its most likely just another dead end. Acually if you look back many atemts of geting elternate meanings out of text by altering the words have just llead absolutely nowhere --UserSolidRock 07:22, 12 Aug 2004 (PDT)
--
-
From the PhaseEmailsFromLadybeeAugustRdAugustEmail, it seems clear that the Sleeping Princess is in fact the author of the ladybee emails (she even is so kind as to sign her name), disproving Extrasonic's speculation. Further, it seems that the Princess does not hold the Flea in high regard ("Nasty little infestation"). Also, the Flea is likely to be a simple program ("he can't write his name or read a book"). -- UserClamatius 18:44, 4 Aug 2004 (PDT)
--
-
Question: Could the Pious Flea be the connection between the The Operator/Queen and the Sleeping Princess? The Queen [bee] may be piping to kill potential threats. The Sleeping Princess may be "queen in waiting," similar to the way queenless hives produce queens (when one emerges, it tries to kill the others). However, reading an article here: http://www.beesource.com/pov/wenner/sci1964.htm (linked from other places in this site), refers to worker bees protecting "possible queens" that have not yet emerged by warding off the Queen and also resealing the potential queens in their cells. The worker bees let the potential queens out one at a time to fight the reigning Queen for the spot. They are also safeguarded just in case the Queen dies while out swarmming... The varrao flea is known to infect bees, could this character be the link between the Princess and the Queen? Could he be the witness (flea on the back)/protector of the Princess? --UserMarno 08-04-2004
--
-
another idea: There wasn't communication with the flea yet - right? Struggling with the weird TextFormating and the ImageSizes I believe these are either messages from the flea or at least his "footprint". And that he hid when the queen looked his way could mean his footprint is only outside the queens messages... Anyway - if my way of thought is correct one could identify a page with the "shore" and the text with "sand". Just 2c. -- UserAgn 11:30, 8 Aug 2004 (PDT)
--
-
Why is the "truth" sought by the Flea turning out to be Melissa's memories? If we entertain the idea of FleaAsCovenantTrojan - arriving via piggybacked virus, maybe - then Melissa's memories would be possibly valuable info for the Covenant. Especially news of a Forerunner artifact recovered. SPECulative leap: The SPDR was trying to carry out the Cole Protocol on Melissa and has been derailed by the Flea, a Covenant AI. Both Melissa and the Flea share similar truthseeking drives - for perhaps opposite sides. PS. from dict.die.com: A flea in the ear, an unwelcome hint or unexpected reply, annoying like a flea; an irritating repulse; as, to put a flea in one's ear; to go away with a flea in one's ear. --UserJellyfishGreen 05:20, 11 Aug 2004 (PDT)
-- I'm not sure that Melissa originally had the truthseeking drive - I think the Flea is rewriting her routines to add its own purpose into hers (the Wormtongue of ILB
). The Flea's mission (given that it's likely a Covenant AI) is almost certainly to live long enough to reveal the true location of Earth. -- UserClamatius 08:55, 12 Aug 2004 (PDT)
But don't the Covenant already know the location of Earth? I thought this happened in Halo: First Strike. (Although I've read it, I've obviously forgotten most of it ...) Actually, now that I think about it, Halo 2 takes place, at least in part, on Earth. The first trailer shows the Covenant attacking Earth, and the Master Chief fighting on Earth. Also, if you read the Halo 2 E3 reports, the multiplayer map they used was Mombassa. Although with alternate timeline stuff, this could still work. (Not sure when the Covenant found out about Earth--I thought during the Fall of Reach, but I could be wrong.) --UserDevolver]] 09:07, 12 Aug 2004 (PDT)
D'oh! (*trouts self*) you're right, they do already know that. Hmm. Clearly it's looking for <i>something</i> in her memories, so then the question is what? -- UserClamatius 09:25, 12 Aug 2004 (PDT)
-
But it was a good idea. I was actually half-way through writing what a good idea I thought you'd had when I remembered that the Covenant had found Earth. Lots of deleting ...
-
Don't toss it out yet. Nobody has yet to report in as to HOW the Covenant got the location of Earth - we only know they do. We don't have an accurate timeline of when the ILB events fit into the Haloverse, so we may very well be dealing with events that occur during First Strike and before Halo 2. This ARG may all be prologue to the game... --UserGunsmithCat 09:46, 12 Aug 2004 (PDT)
In the message posted about the Flea notice MARK is in all caps. Is this to highlight a connection between the Flea and MARK V cyborgs..?
--
This is a bit of a stretch, but bear with me, because I'll make it short. Remember the clockwork rat in the Sleeping Princess' story? I was thinking, and I believe that we are to draw a connection between that rat and the Flea. If I'm correct, the Flea is leading the Operator astray from her true goal; like the girl in the Sleeping Princess' story, Melissa should be wanting to go home, but perhaps is unable to get back by herself. Slowly, Melissa would be turning into something very much different, something much closer in composition to the Flea. Now, for the weak direct connection: rats carry fleas.
I read--and now I can't remember where--that it was a possibility that Melissa had put the Princess in the coffin to protect her. Perhaps this is correct... but perhaps the Flea has corrupted the Operator into thinking that having the Princess in the coffin was for a different reason: Not to keep the outside from getting to the Princess, but to keep the princess from getting to the outside.
Then again, maybe I'm wrong. I request your input, please! - Pericles
-
Personally I think this is a fairly solid theory. However previously Perdita has always represented the SP (See SPMaze). There's also been quite a bit of speculation that Melissa and the SP are in fact two sides or versions of the same AI, so your theory could fit into that. -- SP (I should also point out that I am not the Sleeping Princess. First of all, I'm male. Secondly, SP were my initials first.)
